Luke tells me D&D Basic Set (magenta box) edited by Tom Moldvay is the best. It’s apparently quite lethal – combat has distinct rules, like most D&D, but it’s not .. D&D Rules Cyclopedia is Mentzer Basic, not Moldvay Basic. Which set was “better” – the Basic D&D Moldvay set (the one that you could put in your binder, which came in one single book) or the later set.

Author: Meztishura Meztinos
Country: Serbia
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Spiritual
Published (Last): 20 January 2009
Pages: 465
PDF File Size: 1.95 Mb
ePub File Size: 14.56 Mb
ISBN: 960-6-38654-480-7
Downloads: 26644
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Vudom

He added 6th-level Cleric spells. His wife became the baker while Mentzer acted as manager.

By using this site, you agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy. When Advanced Dungeons and Dragons was released, there was also a set of rules edited and revised by Frank Mentzer.

Delta December 18, at 1: The Conpanion Rules gave us not only domain management rules, but also a mass combat system. Gygax quickly formed New Infinities ProductionsInc. The ur game is simple, warm in tone and forgiving in rules — while painting a harsh, grim world.

I prefer the scale presented in the Basic and Expert sets, without the addition of the Companion, Masters, and Immortals sets.

Posted By Abstruse Thursday, 27th December, Holmes offers dozens of spells level Free exclusively through TabletopGaming. I read Immortals a year or so ago, with my jaw on the floor the whole way through.


The Expert Set expanded upon these rules. Join Date Oct Posts Doug Cowie reviewed the version of the Basic Set for Imagine magazine and gave it a positive review. I feel like the simplicity and warmth of the Moldvay edition out weighs the clarifications of the Mentzer.

Which D&D Basic Set is the best? Tom Moldvay vs. Frank Mentzer – Story Games

To this day, Mentzer himself has never heard of anyone doing this. Dragonlance Forgotten Realms Greyhawk Ravenloft.

This is my first look at Moldvay, and there are parts I like the dungeon in the back and parts that are a bit weird a dagger and a two-handed sword both do 1d6 damage. With Expertthe scope is increased to acceptable levels, with rules for adventuring beyond the dungeon — wilderness, aerial, naval, the world at large — but this doubles the investment required.

Frank Mentzer: The True Master of Dungeons and Dragons

But, this basic set was nothing more than an appetizer. The Companion Set was reviewed by Megan Mentser. I have a hard time imagining what it is oriented towards apart from this by the time you reach 20th level, or any level comparable with the creatures in Deities and D&v which is a long-winded way of saying I agree with Mike. David Cook and Stephen R. The back of the card describes a brief scenario to illustrate the rules discussed on the front.

Which D&D Basic Set is the best? Tom Moldvay vs. Frank Mentzer…

But when I look at that book now, I menyzer every bad idea that got culled from Moldvay. Some articles have Vimeo videos embedded in them. Moldvay’s game is pretty d&e and straightforward.


The rules would work for your game group for a few months at the most! I will come back to check on you. Not a big deal, but a totally fun character who I want to play. Javascript software libraries such as jQuery are loaded at endpoints on the googleapis. It’d be a year or two real time before that’d be an issue, but it never hurts to start early.

Holmes presents the game as rules to be followed. Dungeons and Dragons version 3.

Dungeons & Dragons Basic Set – Wikipedia

Retrieved October 17, Sign mentser or sign up and post using a HubPages Network account. And this is a valid question. Advanced was the better game, they would claim.

It also introduces the optional character class of druidpresented as a special progression for clerics of neutral alignment. Gary Gygax’s magnum opus. No one ever gets to fourth level. I beginning to think a trip down to the FLGS is in order and I need to see if there’s a copy of the Companion book s in the used bin.